Rendering of modern design option for the West Heating Plant.
ANC 2E voted to pass two caveat-riddled resolutions related to the redevelopment of the long-dormant Georgetown West Heating Plant on Monday night: one to make record of their issues with the redevelopment proposal, and the other to opt out of the forthcoming demolition debate.
A development team of The Four Seasons, the Levy Group, and the Georgetown Companies seeks to erect a 60-70 unit luxury condominium property on the Georgetown West Heating Plant site at 1051-1055 29th Street NW (map). The plant is in a historic district and is considered a contributing structure, although it was denied landmark status by the Historic Preservation Review Board last year.
In December, architect David Adjaye presented two options for the new building’s design to the community: the first an update of the renderings presented two years ago, meant to recall the plant currently on the site; the second, a more ambitious design meant to evoke both the eminence of the vista of monuments along the Potomac River and the warmth of residential Georgetown.
In response to community input, the development team is moving forward with the latter proposal which the Citizens Association of Georgetown stated their support for on Monday night. Similarly, The Friends of Georgetown Waterfront Park furnished a letter of support to demolish the plant and replace it with a park and residences, although they declined to throw their weight behind a specific plan.
Rendering of modern design option as seen from originally-designed public park.
Although many ANC and community members agree that the plant is an eyesore, a few still have reservations about what should be done going forward. Some believe that Georgetown’s status as a neighborhood of historic character and importance would be undermined by the construction of an obviously modern (and potentially place-less) new development. Others think that a high-quality modern building would be a worthy continuation of Georgetown’s mix of various architectural styles and periods — preferable to an imitation of a historic style.
Ultimately, the ANC approved a resolution which offered their critique of the design with the primary objection that the proposed building’s height and massing is still too large. The majority of ANC commissioners agreed that the new building should more closely adhere to nearby residential and hotel buildings — including the adjacent six-story Four Seasons hotel. This resolution also included other points of contention which the ANC acknowledged that the development team has already addressed to varying extents (e.g. access to nearby bicycling paths, distance from the canal’s edge, etc.).
As for whether to support demolition of the plant, the ANC opted to pass an amended resolution to take no position on the demolition, with the recommendation that the proposal go through all of the proper bureaucratic channels in order to secure a lawful demolition. Two commissioners opposed the resolution on the grounds that the resolution not only reiterated several points which were already belabored during the HPRB landmark-denial process (eg. feasibility of rehabilitating the Plant building, deed covenants, etc.), but also included various issues which may be beyond the ANC’s realm of expertise.
The development team will present its proposal to the Old Georgetown Board on Thursday, another in a lengthy series of presentations and applications to secure the demolition permits and design approval.
Correction: An earlier version of the title and article misstated the nature of the resolutions adopted. Rather than expressing approval for either, the ANC stated their desire that the demolition be determined after all stages in the legal process have been satisfied, and enumerated their issues with the design.
This article originally published at http://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/the_anc_2e_debates_georgetown_west_heating_plant_project/10827
Most Popular... This Week • Last 30 Days • Ever
This week’s Best New Listings includes a colonial in Historic Hyattsville, a classi... read »
The H Street Corridor once epitomized DC's development boom, but construction activit... read »
UrbanTurf is taking a look at what we think will be the three metrics that will deter... read »
Built in 1840, the home has been home to members of Congress and presidential cabinet... read »
A look at the close-in cities in Maryland and Virginia with the lowest supply of home... read »
UrbanTurf is re-running its primer on property taxes which outlines a few things that... read »
UrbanTurf has compiled virtual looks at large new developments around the DC region.... read »
The Shaw pipeline is starting the year off hot.... read »
The upzoning would mandate additional Inclusionary Zoning units for developments alon... read »
Is U Street regaining steam as the development center of gravity in the neighborhood?... read »
With this weekend's DC houseboat tour a day away, UrbanTurf thought it only fitting t... read »
President Obama travels to Denver this morning to sign the stimulus bill that has bee... read »
In this week's installment of Ask An Agent, a reader wonders if there is a rule for h... read »
As The Wharf prepares to begin construction, DC's houseboat community heads to its ne... read »
In this week's installment of Ask An Agent, a reader asks a fairly common question th... read »
DC Real Estate Guides
Short guides to navigating the DC-area real estate market
We've collected all our helpful guides for buying, selling and renting in and around Washington, DC in one place. Visit guides.urbanturf.com or start browsing below!
Intro guides for first-time home buyers
Awesome and unusual real estate from across the DC Metro