A Co-op Building That Pays Its Owners

• April 15, 2013
• 2 Comments

by Shilpi Paul

At 464 Broome Street, tenants get $20,000/year.

An article in The New York Times over the weekend introduced us to a concept that seems almost too good to believe: the Big Apple has co-op buildings where residents pay no maintenance fees and also make money off the property’s commercial tenants.

If you have walked around New York, you are no doubt aware that many residential buildings in the city have ground-floor retail tenants. As it turns out, a luxury shop in a high-end district could potential pay enough in rent every month to completely offset maintenance fees for homeowners in the building, and in some cases, provide the owners with a sizable yearly dividend.

Until 2007, however, this wasn’t all too common as a federal tax law capped the amount of income that co-op buildings could generate from their retail tenants; according to the law, in order to qualify as a housing cooperative, 80 percent of the income of a co-op had to come from the owners themselves (and no more than 20 percent needed to come from the retailer). The 80/20 rule was the only way for co-ops to maintain their tax status as a housing cooperative. So, in order to maintain the 80/20 ratio, many co-ops rented their retail spaces for below market rate.

After 2007, the law was loosened. The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 gave co-ops a couple other ways to maintain their tax status, like proving that 80 percent of the square footage in the building was used by tenant shareholders or that 90 percent of the expenses were spent in the benefit of tenant shareholders.

As a result, many co-op buildings started increasing the rent on their retail tenants. Some buildings renovated their retail spaces in order to attract higher-end stores, and tenants have been able to really cash in. According to the Times, a building at 464 Broome Street in SoHo, earns so much retail rental income that owners receive a $20,000 annual payment.

From the Times:

“The building has just eight apartments,” said Henry Hershkowitz, a broker at Douglas Elliman who represented a seller [of one unit], “so the revenues from the two stores on the ground floor cover the real estate taxes, the building’s upkeep, even a full-time super, and then there is money left over for an annual dividend.”

The federal tax law adjustments apply across the country, so presumably DC buildings are taking that under consideration.

This article originally published at https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/is_it_possible_to_live_in_a_maintenance-free_coop/6932

2 Comments

1. Mari said at 1:45 pm on Tuesday April 16, 2013:
   That's wonderful, residents directly profiting from neighborhood gentrification.

1. Tom M said at 9:34 pm on Thursday April 18, 2013:
   The building rental income from the two commercial properties reportedly pays all those costs and generates a $16k/year dividend. You'd have to park $320,000 at 5% annual return to generate that kind of return. Unless you are a "pre-gentrification" owner, you don't get the benefit as the value of the income stream and the lower costs will be baked in to the sale price for the new sucker...ahm I mean buyer.