Construction Companies Save 17 Percent Through Illegal Worker Misclassification, Per Report

• September 12th 2019

by Nena Perry-Brown

✉️ Want to forward this article? Click here.

Misclassification of employees as independent contractors is a tale as old as payroll taxes, and the construction industry is no exception. Labor costs are a major facet of the recent ballooning of construction costs nationwide, and now, the District is scrutinizing how construction firms are cutting corners to save on costs.

Yesterday, the city's Office of the Attorney General (OAG) released a report shedding light on how construction companies in DC use worker misclassification to save on labor costs. In general, the responsibilities owed to and expected from independent contractors tend to be less demanding for the employer and less restrictive for the individual than for traditional employees. Some companies illegally classify individuals who work for them as an independent contractor, despite those individuals being treated as an employee, in order to reduce the administrative cost. This also has the effect of shifting administrative costs to the worker and disenfranchising the misclassified worker from access to unemployment, benefits, worker's compensation, overtime and the like.

For the construction industry, these illegally-acquired cost savings enable firms to submit more fiscally attractive bids for construction jobs, undercutting competing firms which don't engage in misclassification. The report assumes an average hourly labor cost of $36.91 for legally-classified workers and $31.64 for illegally-classified workers, netting a respective $30.43 or $26.80 in take home wages for the worker, a difference of at least 11.5 percent. 

"The cost evasion of illegally misclassifying workers in the District’s construction industry begins at 16.7 percent, which companies can use to underbid and undercut high-road employers," the report states. This means that employers which illegally misclassify workers can expect to save $16.70 per $100 paid in labor costs. Even worse, when factoring in how unlikely it is that the profits from cost evasion are "passed on" to workers in the form of benefits, this cost evasion is closer to 48 percent.

“Companies that illegally misclassify employees as independent contractors are stealing from workers, evading taxes, and gaining an unlawful edge over competitors,” Attorney General Karl Racine said in a statement. “The Office of the Attorney General commissioned this study to better understand the dynamics of worker misclassification and how we can fight it.”

The OAG currently is investigating or pursuing action against some construction companies and contractors, and sued electrical subcontractor Power Design last year for misclassification. 

This article originally published at https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/construction-companies-save-17-percent-through-illegal-worker-misclassifica/15869.