Will 4.5 Percent Interest Rates Soon Become a Reality?

It is now widely-known that the Treasury Department is considering a plan that would encourage banks to drop interest rates for new home loans to 4.5 percent, a full point lower than some of the lowest rates currently available for standard 30-year fixed-rate mortgages. Even though the plan is in its very early stages, just the talk that rates might drop to these historically low levels (and the fact that just yesterday the Federal Reserve cut its benchmark interest rate to almost zero) has gotten the attention of prospective home buyers. But with rates that are already lower than they have been in years (under 6 percent), does it make sense to wait for something that may never come?
“I think the people that are on the fence (to buy) are saying to themselves that they should wait to see if it actually happens,” Mandy Mills of Hounshell Real Estate told UrbanTurf. “People who are ready to buy are not waiting around.”
Mills’ partner David Getson was more emphatic.
“Quite frankly, I think the media is doing a general disservice to the market as a whole by putting the 4.5 percent number out there,” Getson said. “At this point, the details are very unclear, particularly who can actually qualify for the new rate.”
Getson is correct in that, at this point, very little is known about the program. However, the general perception is that the proposed plan will only help those who want to buy homes, not those who want to refinance. It is also thought that steady employment and a good credit history will be criteria that will be needed to qualify.
Let’s imagine for a moment that rates are cut to 4.5 percent. That means that if you put a 20 percent down payment on a $500,000 home, your loan payments will come to about $2,000 a month (assuming you get a 30-year fixed rate mortgage). Compare those payments with what you would be paying at 5.5 percent, and you are saving about $250 a month. Here are a few more monthly payment comparisons, based on a 30-year fixed rate mortgage:
| Home Price | Loan (80%) | 5.5 Percent | 4.5 Percent | Monthly Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 | $200,000 | $1,135 | $1,013 | $122 |
| $375,000 | $300,000 | $1,703 | $1,520 | $183 |
| $625,000 | $500,000 | $2,838 | $2,533 | $305 |
While certainly enticing, these numbers could have the unfortunate result of people thinking that they can afford something they can’t. In other words, the low rates may tempt buyers to go one step above the property that they would’ve otherwise purchased. This is a dangerous leap in a time when layoffs are announced in the headlines daily and job security is so precarious. Besides, one of the reasons that the market is in the state that it is in is because consumers were biting off more of a mortgage than they could chew.
What’s more is that the plan is still in the discussion phase and may not be made final before the current administration’s term ends. This would mean that action would not be taken until Congress reconvenes next year. As such, the general consensus is that buyers who have their eyes set on a new home would be foolish to let it slip through their fingers for a rate that may never come. And 4.5 percent may indeed be too good to be true.
“I would love to see it get that low, but I am cautiously optimistic,” Leslie Wilder of McEnearney Associates told UrbanTurf. “I have a hard time seeing it happen.”
Join the discussion
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.Most Popular... This Week • Last 30 Days • Ever

For this week's price-guessing game of homes in other metropolitan areas, we head... read »
Neighborhood Profiles more »
Deanwood: A Little Bit of Country Just Inside the District’s Borders
Amanda Abrams
August 25th | 5 Comments
Located east of the Anacostia River and just inside the District’s northeast border, Deanwood has... read »
Editor's Choice more »
Despite Shrinking Inventory, Financing for Condo Projects Hard to Come By
Ryan Holeywell
August 27th | 3 Comments
Over the past several months, the dark cloud that has hung over the DC area condo market since it... read »
- Despite Shrinking Inventory, Financing for Condo Projects Hard to Come By
- DC Real Estate’s Real Unicorn: One-Bedroom Houses
- The Heartbroken Buyer Syndrome
- Georgetown Landmark General Store Back on Market
- Unique Spaces: Sears Bungalow Gets a Modern Makeover
New Condo Profiles more »
14th and S Street Residential Project Likely to be Condos
Mark Wellborn
August 24th | 2 Comments
14th and You recently posted a very comprehensive preview of the 125-unit residential project that... read »
The DC Condo Market more »
Despite Shrinking Inventory, Financing for Condo Projects Hard to Come By
Ryan Holeywell
August 27th | 3 Comments
Over the past several months, the dark cloud that has hung over the DC area condo market since it... read »
Green Real Estate more »
UrbanTurf Reader Asks: What Effect Will Adding Solar Panels Have on the Value of My Home?
Mark Wellborn
1:30 PM EDT | 3 Comments
In this week's installment of UrbanTurf Reader Asks, a reader wonders what the long-term benefits... read »
- UrbanTurf Reader Asks: What Effect Will Adding Solar Panels Have on the Value of My Home?
- Unique Spaces: Frank Lloyd Wright Goes Green in Kensington
- 14th and U to Go Green
- How Much Energy Do You Use? Microsoft Hohm Will Tell You
- Unique Spaces: A Studio 27 Renovation on Capitol Hill
Deal of the Week more »
Deal of the Week: 720 Square Feet on the Cheap in Dupont
Mark Wellborn
August 9th | 10 Comments
In this week's installment of Deal of the Week, we find a corner one-bedroom co-op in Dupont Circle... read »
- Deal of the Week: 720 Square Feet on the Cheap in Dupont
- Deal of the Week: BBQing in Columbia Heights
- Deal of the Week: A Price Per Square Foot Special in Logan Circle
- Deal of the Week: Buy This With a Friend
- Deal of the Week: All Renovated in Mount Pleasant
Renting more »
The Inside Scoop on The Newseum Residences
Carisa Chappell
September 1st | 4 Comments
The Newseum Residences at the corner of 6th Street and Pennsylvania Avenue NW cater to news... read »
- The Inside Scoop on The Newseum Residences
- Four Takes on Tenant Rights in DC
- CityVista V Apartments Sold
- The Kennedy-Warren: The “Old Lady” of Washington
- Amateur Landlord: Picking the Right Tenant
Condo Buyers more »
Metropole Has Five Units Remaining
Mark Wellborn
August 25th | 0 Comments
UrbanTurf recently learned that the Metropole condominium in Logan Circle has just five units left... read »
- Metropole Has Five Units Remaining
- 14th and S Street Residential Project Likely to be Condos
- Sponsored: 5 Tips for Buying a Condo in Fall 2010
- Potomac Station: Condos Just Upstairs From the Neighborhood Deli
- The Matisse: Not Your Average Boutique Condo
Unique Spaces more »
Old Town General Store Becomes Three-Level Home
Jennifer Sergent
August 16th | 5 Comments
In this installment of Unique Spaces, we head over to Old Town, Alexandria where a general store... read »
- Old Town General Store Becomes Three-Level Home
- Sears Bungalow Gets a Modern Makeover
- Frank Lloyd Wright Goes Green in Kensington
- Throwing a Curve at 550 Square Feet
- The Bank that Became a Home
DC Buyer more »
DC Physician Looking for Traditional Two-Bedroom Home
Martin Smith
August 6th | 12 Comments
In this week's DC Buyer, we are working with Nioke, a 32 year-old physician who currently rents in... read »
UrbanTurf Reader Asks more »
What Effect Will Adding Solar Panels Have on the Value of My Home?
Mark Wellborn
1:30 PM EDT | 3 Comments
In this week's installment of UrbanTurf Reader Asks, a reader wonders what the long-term benefits... read »
What X Buys You more »
What Does $625K Buy You in DC?
Rebecca Ortega
August 30th | 7 Comments
In place of Best New Listings this week, we look at properties in the $625,000 range to give... read »
Best New Listings more »
Best New Listings: End of August Edition (Week of Aug 23rd)
UrbanTurf Staff
August 23rd | 0 Comments
The end of August usually offers slim pickings in terms of new real estate hitting the market, but... read »
- Best New Listings: End of August Edition (Week of Aug 23rd)
- Best New Listings: Dupont Circle and Columbia Heights (Week of Aug 8th)
- Best New Listings: Mount Pleasant and Chevy Chase (Week of Aug 2nd)
- Best New Listings: The Numbered Streets Edition (Week of Jul 25th)
- Best New Listings: Adams Morgan and Capitol Hill (Week of Jul 19th)
Luxury Real Estate more »
$220 Million = World’s Most Expensive Home
Mark Wellborn
August 13th | 1 Comment
A home buyer recently paid the equivalent of $220 million for a six-bedroom penthouse in London,... read »


































































4 Comments
If this happens I hope they aren’t so foolish to only offer the lower rate on new purchases. In theory this would help reduce inventory, but in a way it also provides an incentive for owners whose rates are higher or possibly resetting to a higher rate to sell their current home in order to buy another home at the reduced rate. This would have the adverse effect of putting more homes on the market. If such a plan were to proceed it should be for both purchases and refinances (normal guidelines required in each). Such a policy would also largely mitigate the “wait for the lower rate” attitude that is potentially slowing the market down right now.
I agree that folks “biting off more than they can chew” have prompted much of the current financial mess. I disagree that this is likely to be a problem with any new 4.5% program introduced through Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac at this time. Underwriting guidelines have swung quite far away from the virtually non existent qualifying criteria of a few years ago.
Fannie and Freddie actually remained quite conservative compared to the loans that really got us in trouble. If Fannie and Freddy ended up owning a significant number of sub prime loans I would be willing to bet that they bought them under some sort of political duress.
I believe it was investment bankers like Bear Stearns who learned how to securitize loans and gradually gutted qualifying criteria down to nothing. I am sure at the peak; these firms had so much money flowing in to be turned into loans that they needed to reduce qualifying guidelines just to create borrowers enough to absorb it all. All the while Fannie and Freddie guidelines remained quite sound.
As of today, the underwriting pendulum has swung so far the other way that most homeowners who are comfortably making their current payments would probably have a hard time qualifying for a new Fannie Mae loan even if it carried a lower payment.
Wake up everyone, some lenders are already offering 4.5%! Totally disagree with JT’s comment about homeowners wanting to sell their homes to cash in on the lower rate. Are you kidding me? The big “IF” is whether or not they can sell their existing house in this market without taking a loss. If they are lucky enough to sell at a reasonable price, I’m not sure many of them would want to immediatly puchase an asset that may continue to drop in value… especially in the short-term.
I don’t think the media is did a disservice as David Getson mentions. The Treasury should have not mentioned it - they did the disservice. We have buyers in our marketplace that are now waiting for the lower rate. Our rates are holding steady at 5%. It’s my understanding that when it happens there will be a pool on money and when it’s gone, up go the rates. So, the buyers that wait might not gain. http://www.ErieRealEstateBlogs.com