Trulia: Buying 34% Cheaper than Renting in DC Area

• October 15th 2014

by Lark Turner

Buying a home remains cheaper than renting in the DC region, according to an analysis from Trulia released on Wednesday.

Specifically buying a home is 34 percent cheaper than renting, according to the company’s analysis, a percentage unchanged since early in 2014. Nationwide, it’s on average 38 percent cheaper to buy than to rent.

Trulia’s chief economist Jed Kolko provided UrbanTurf more fine-grained data that shows how the payoff from buying over renting can vary depending on where in the DC area you live:

Fairfax, VA: 25% cheaper
Loudoun, VA: 26% cheaper
Arlington and Alexandria, VA: 30% cheaper
District of Columbia: 33% cheaper
Montgomery County, MD: 34% cheaper
Prince William, VA: 35% cheaper
Prince George’s, MD: 57% cheaper

As we have reported when covering this analysis in the past, it is important to understand the criteria that Trulia uses when determining if it is cheaper to buy than rent in a metropolitan area.

The company calculates the figures assuming a 20 percent down payment on a 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage financed with a 4.3 percent interest rate. It assumes people itemize their federal tax deductions and are in the 25 percent tax bracket, and factors in renovation and maintenance costs, as well as insurance, utilities, and property taxes at the average metro property tax rate. For renters, the company tacks on renters’ insurance.

Perhaps most significant in the calculations is that Trulia assumes that a homeowner will live in the home for at least seven years.

The company’s rent vs. buy calculator can factor in alternative financing, including different types of mortgages and down payment amounts. Trulia ran calculations on different financing options and found that nationwide, buying was cheaper than renting every time.

Trulia notes that seven years may be a long time to stay in one place, especially in a pricey market. Despite the cost differences, buying may not be for everyone:

If you live in a market that’s a close call, and you plan to stay less than seven years, don’t itemize your tax deductions, or need an FHA loan, buying might not be the clear-cut winner. Indeed, if many or all of these things apply to you, buying could end up costing far more than renting. Buying may be 38% cheaper than renting nationally, but there are still plenty of people for whom renting would cost less than buying, even if low down payment loans give them the option to buy.

This article originally published at https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/trulia_buying_still_a_lot_cheaper_than_renting_in_dc/9098.