Courtesy of Vision McMillan
On Thursday, the Historic Preservation Review Board gave Vision McMillan Partners their remaining thoughts on the buildings proposed for the redevelopment of the McMillan Sand Filtration site. Two weeks ago, the development team went before the board to present plans for the buildings, which fall under four categories: the recreation center, the townhouses, a mixed-use apartment and grocery complex, and the medical office buildings. Though they relayed comments at the June meeting, the board gave the majority of their thoughts to the group on Thursday.
Overall, the board was unimpressed with the designs and charged the developers with coming back with a revision that addressed their many comments. In addition to a lack of coherence among the various buildings, which were designed by different architects, some board members felt that the historical elements of the site were not enough of a focal point.
“Let [the buildings] be unified and similar, and let the silos stand apart,” said one board member. “The new construction should be subservient to the historic assets,” reiterated another.
The mixed-use building.
Several members of the board noted that the community center was the strongest of the four buildings proposed, while the mixed-use building, a cross-shaped structure with repurposed metal materials, was the most controversial. A few board members hinted that it was over-designed while others thought that it was conceptually strong, but didn’t approve of the shape and orientation.
The townhouses generated little enthusiasm. The board offered a few ideas on how to improve the design, either by choosing materials more carefully, or perhaps creating groups of rowhouses with individual entries and simplifying the colors. “Instead of vertical row houses, what about grouped row houses with individual entry, and less color diversity,” Board chair Gretchen Pfaehler said.
Medical Office buildings
The board voted to approve the master plan guidelines, but asked the applicants to come back with a revised design to address the litany of comments and criticism laid out at the meeting.
“I think this project points out how difficult it is to create a community from scratch,” noted Board member Graham Davidson.
- More Cohesive: HPRB Weighs in on McMillan Buildings
- The Buildings: More Renderings Released Of McMillan Redevelopment
This article originally published at http://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/hprb_recommends_major_changes_to_mcmillan_redevelopment_plans/7308
Most Popular... This Week • Last 30 Days • Ever
The Somerset House, an 84-unit building at 16th and S Street NW, is converting from... read »
Political consultants Mary Matalin and James Carville purchased a 5,000 square-foot... read »
The trouble with open-concept kitchens; the elusive million-dollar home; and a NoMa... read »
UrbanTurf is taking a look at neighborhood-specific housing statistics with the help... read »
How to do concrete floors right; student debt keeping first-time homebuyers from... read »
Eataly has signed a letter of intent for somewhere in the vicinity of 30,000 to... read »
Small living is about to take on a whole new meaning on one of the city's hippest... read »
An oversupply of apartments and an undersupply of condos can't be fixed by... read »
A new Zillow study examined affordability by zip code in the country's top metros.... read »
How much does a deeded parking spot run you in the District? And what about renting?... read »
With this weekend's DC houseboat tour a day away, UrbanTurf thought it only fitting... read »
President Obama travels to Denver this morning to sign the stimulus bill that has... read »
At Wednesday night's ANC 2F Design Review Committee meeting, developers presented... read »
As The Wharf prepares to begin construction, DC's houseboat community heads to its... read »
In this week's installment of Ask An Agent, a reader asks a fairly common question... read »
DC Real Estate Guides
Short guides to navigating the DC-area real estate market
We’ve collected all our helpful guides for buying, selling and renting in and around Washington, DC in one place. Visit guides.urbanturf.com or start browsing below!