What's Hot: The Georgetown Wall is Still For Sale | HPO Recommends Approval For Office-to-Residential Conversion in Dupont
Blagden Alley Micro-Unit Development Gains HPRB Support

Rendering of proposed Blagden Alley development.
Despite a staff report that criticized the development and recommended its rejection, SB-Urban’s proposed 125-unit building in Shaw’s Blagden Alley received support from the Historic Preservation Review Board (HPRB) on Thursday, contingent on the developer making some changes to the design and perhaps coming back before the board for a cursory look at those design changes to win final support.
(Whether or not the board recommended the developer return for final approval was unclear even to staffers at HPRB on Thursday afternoon.)
The project, which includes two buildings fronting 9th and M Streets (map), is linked by a pedestrian bridge. The development combines very small, furnished rentals with generous amenity spaces for socializing. The amenities are located in the larger M Street building, so the pedestrian bridge gives the 9th Street building’s occupants easier access to the amenities. SB-Urban is working with architect Hickok Cole on the project.
Brendan Meyer, the staff reviewer who had recommended the project be changed significantly, said the design departed “from the pattern of the alley architecture” and would “incompatibly change the scale of this historic district.” But Meyer said the design of the buildings overall were compatible with their context on 9th and M Streets.

But HPRB Chair Gretchen Pfaehler praised the developer’s community outreach — no one showed up to oppose the project — and the overall design. Board member Maria Casarella called the project “delightful.”
The board’s recommended changes did not include the elimination of the pedestrian bridge or eliminating building setbacks the developer proposed to widen the alley and make it more pedestrian-friendly. But board members did vote to require the bridge to be more of a catwalk, open to the elements rather than enclosed by glass. That may make things a little less comfortable for the building’s tenants come winter.
Nancy Metzger, a board member who voted against the design and opposed the bridge, said the building’s occupants could easily walk from one end of the narrow alley to the other.
“It takes me 10 seconds to walk from one side of the alley to the other,” Metzger said. “These hardy millennials, it’s nothing to them. Ten seconds doesn’t strike me as an overwhelming task.”
A resolution to approve the project, with some changes to the design, passed narrowly, 4-3. Metzger, Joseph Taylor and Charles Wilson voted against the project, while Pfaehler, Casarella, Andrew Aurbach and Rauzia Ally voted in favor of it, with Pfaehler’s proposed modifications to the bridge and some other, smaller design elements.
Steve Callcott of the Historic Preservation Office called the outcome a compromise typical of the board.
“We took a position and made a decision in a very close vote, and accepted a middle-of-the-road approach to changing the design,” he told UrbanTurf. “It’s more a matter of degree than it is a fundamental disagreement.”
See other articles related to: blagden alley, historic, hprb, micro-units, sb-urban
This article originally published at https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/sb-urbans_blagden_alley_development_gets_historic_support_with_some_change/8809.
Most Popular... This Week • Last 30 Days • Ever

The listing will hit the market on Wednesday, according to the Washington Business Jo... read »

Here are some precautions to take before buying real estate with a buddy.... read »

The concept for the residential conversion of a prominently sited building in Dupont ... read »

About a month ago, UrbanTurf examined how condo and co-op prices were driving home pr... read »

Even though flipping is not as prevalent in the city as it used to be, there are sti... read »
- Inside Bradley Beal's $10 Million Bethesda Home
- Buying with Friends: What You Should Know
- HPO Recommends Approval For 157-Unit Office-to-Residential Conversion Proposed in Dupont Circle
- More Down Than Up: A Look at Detached Home Prices Around DC
- Home Flipping Drops in DC, But Three Zip Codes Are Still Seeing Profits
DC Real Estate Guides
Short guides to navigating the DC-area real estate market
We've collected all our helpful guides for buying, selling and renting in and around Washington, DC in one place. Start browsing below!
First-Timer Primers
Intro guides for first-time home buyers
Unique Spaces
Awesome and unusual real estate from across the DC Metro