WSJ: Does the Tax Credit Really Make a Difference?

by Mark Wellborn

image

Brett Arends, The Wall Street Journal columnist who does a good job of explaining financial issues in layman’s terms, examines whether or not the expanding home buyer credit would be a good deal for buyers in his most recent column.

In a post earlier this week, we wrote that the Senate passed a proposal that would extend the credit to home purchases under contract by April 30, 2010 and it would be available to individuals earning up to $125,000, or $250,000 for couples, up from $75,000 for individuals and $150,000 for couples under the current law. The proposal would also let homeowners qualify for a $6,500 credit if they have lived in their residence for five years.

However, according to Arends’ column, the credit will really only make a difference in places where homes are really cheap:

For example, it may provide a helpful shot in the arm for the stricken real estate market in Nevada (where Sen. Reid faces a tough re-election battle next year) more than in high-priced coastal markets like Silicon Valley and New York City.

According to Zillow.com, the median home price in Las Vegas right now is just $139,000. That compares to $562,000 in San Jose, California and $795,000 in Manhattan.

So the maximum $8,000 credit will cover about 6% of the median price in Vegas, but barely 1% in the most-expensive areas.

For your reference, Redfin says that the current median list price for homes in the DC area is currently $350,000.

3 Comments

  1. computer consultant said at 10:42 am on Monday November 2, 2009:

    The better question is where the goverment is going to get the money to finance all this?

  1. Mike said at 11:37 am on Monday November 2, 2009:

    The answer to the question above - the same place they did for the stimulus and every other bailout—print it.

    If you are looking to buy and can afford to buy - who in their right mind won’t take a free $8K.  That is a few months of mortgage payments (maybe not in DC but I’ll take it).

  1. Tom A. said at 5:00 pm on Monday November 2, 2009:

    Just remember than in DC you get 5k anyway, so after 11/30 the 8k is reduced only by 3k.

    You can’t take both.

Join the discussion



* required fields

Find An Agent in the DC Metro Region

UrbanTurf Archive

Following are past UrbanTurf stories, organized by topic for your convenience.

Neighborhood Profiles more »

Capitol Riverfront: Still Growing

Capitol Riverfront: Still Growing

Tim Brown
March 8th | 21 Comments

Despite being one of the areas in DC hit hardest by the economic downturn, Capitol Riverfront,... read »

Editor's Choice more »

A Proposal: Georgetown Should Secede From DC

A Proposal: Georgetown Should Secede From DC

Mark Wellborn
March 10th | 10 Comments

In a post that is sure to incite the ire of DC residents, Carol Joynt, a DC columnist for New York... read »

New Condo Profiles more »

M Street Flats: Fast-Selling Boutique Condos in Mt. Vernon Triangle

M Street Flats: Fast-Selling Boutique Condos in Mt. Vernon Triangle

Jeremy Castle
March 15th | 2 Comments

Even with only hard-hat construction tours available of M Street Flats in Mount Vernon Triangle,... read »

The DC Condo Market more »

Remaining New Condos in the DC Metro: Where Are They?

Remaining New Condos in the DC Metro: Where Are They?

Will Smith
February 16th | 6 Comments

The recent report on the new condo market from McWilliams|Ballard includes tallies of the remaining... read »

Green Real Estate more »

What $469K Buys You in DC?

What $469K Buys You in DC?

Mark Wellborn
March 10th | 5 Comments

In this week's installment of What X Buys You, we look at a two-bedroom row house in Shaw that was... read »

Deal of the Week more »

Deal of the Week: Columbia Heights Convenience for Cheap

Deal of the Week: Columbia Heights Convenience for Cheap

Mark Wellborn
March 16th | 3 Comments

For this week's Deal of the Week, we look at a two-bedroom condo on Columbia Road that is just... read »

Renting more »

Rent vs. Buy: Cleveland Park

Rent vs. Buy: Cleveland Park

Michele Lerner
March 19th | 2 Comments

In Rent vs. Buy this week, UrbanTurf looks at Cleveland Park, a neighborhood whose mix of... read »

Condo Buyers more »

20 Sales in 20 Days at The Floridian in the U Street Corridor

20 Sales in 20 Days at The Floridian in the U Street Corridor

Will Smith
March 19th | 5 Comments

Since its grand re-opening late last month, The Floridian is selling units at a rate of about one... read »

Unique Spaces more »

Unique Spaces: Tilden Street Restaurant Becomes Spacious Home

Tilden Street Restaurant Becomes Spacious Home

Mark Wellborn
March 2nd | 16 Comments

There are likely very few people in the DC area who can say that they live in a former restaurant.... read »

DC Buyer more »

DC Buyer: Small Business Owner Looking for Live/Work Space

Small Business Owner Looking for Live/Work Space

Martin Smith
March 17th | 3 Comments

In this week's DC Buyer, we’re working with Alex, a small business owner looking for a live/work... read »

UrbanTurf Reader Asks more »

UrbanTurf Reader Asks: Are DC Homeowners Seeing Their Tax Assessments Increase?

Are DC Homeowners Seeing Their Tax Assessments Increase?

Mark Wellborn
March 9th | 8 Comments

In this week’s installment of UrbanTurf Reader Asks, a reader who bought a foreclosure in 2009 and... read »

Ask an Agent more »

Ask an Agent: Should I Buy a Parking Space That is Separate From My Unit?

Should I Buy a Parking Space That is Separate From My Unit?

Mark Wellborn
December 9th | 2 Comments

In this week's installment of Ask An Agent, a reader who bought a condo last year wonders if he... read »

Best New Listings more »

Best New Listings: Adams Morgan and 16th Street Heights

Best New Listings: Adams Morgan and 16th Street Heights (Week of Mar 14th)

Mark Wellborn
March 14th | 1 Comment

This week's Best New Listings include a two-bedroom penthouse co-op in Adams Morgan with parking... read »

Luxury Real Estate more »

Guess the Price: Vegas, Vegas, Vegas

Guess the Price: Vegas, Vegas, Vegas

Mark Wellborn
March 19th | 6 Comments

UrbanTurf representatives are currently taking in some March Madness basketball in Las Vegas, so it... read »