UrbanTurf Reader Asks: Should I Buy a Rowhouse in Mount Pleasant or Petworth?

Mount Pleasant Rowhouses by NCinDC
In this week’s installment of UrbanTurf Reader Asks, a reader who is in the market for a row house wonders if she should sacrifice space and price for convenience by buying in Mount Pleasant over Petworth.
“I admit that this could be an annoying question for some, but I am having a lot of trouble deciding between whether to buy a row house in Petworth or in Mount Pleasant. The pros of Petworth are more space for your money and probably a little more upside for resale value in 3-5 years given the increased development going on in the neighborhood. Mount Pleasant is slightly more expensive, but has a little more character and is more centrally located. I know that this decision also boils down to which neighborhood I like more, but quite honestly, I like them both equally. Thanks for your input.
Post your thoughts in the comments section. If you would like to submit a question for UrbanTurf Reader Asks, send an email to .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).
Join the discussion
Most Popular... This Week • Last 30 Days • Ever

Real estate sales and marketing firm McWilliams|Ballard has released a report on the... read »
Neighborhood Profiles more »
From Seedy to Sought-After: Mount Vernon Triangle Becoming Urban Village
Will Smith
February 1st | 4 Comments
As part of UrbanTurf’s continuing partnership with The Washington Post, we published an article... read »
- From Seedy to Sought-After: Mount Vernon Triangle Becoming Urban Village
- Logan Circle: Trendy Now, But Not By Accident
- H Street: A Place To Party, and To Settle Down
- Foggy Bottom: Students, Skyscrapers and the State Department
- Columbia Heights: DC's Best Destination for New Home Owners?
Editor's Choice more »
DC Condo Fees: From $100 to $1,000
Michele Lerner
February 2nd | 12 Comments
Condo fees in DC vary significantly from building to building and neighborhood to neighborhood.... read »
- DC Condo Fees: From $100 to $1,000
- From Seedy to Sought-After: Mount Vernon Triangle Becoming Urban Village
- DC’s Housing Scarcity: Great for Sellers, Frustrating for Buyers
- DC Buyer: The 30 Year-Old Teacher in 16th Street Heights
- The Presidential Party Crasher’s Pad
New Condo Profiles more »
900 North Washington Street: Old Town Condos Seeing Green
Jeremy Castle
January 12th | 0 Comments
900 North Washington Street is a new 57-unit development in Old Town, Alexandria with condos meant... read »
- 900 North Washington Street: Old Town Condos Seeing Green
- The Woodley Wardman: New Condos Amidst Old Money
- The Residences at Liberty Center: Comfortable Convenience With a View
- Waterfront Tower: A Green Condo in The Little Quadrant That Could
- Carry Lofts: For the Man Who Brought Ice Cream and Beer to Capitol Hill
The DC Condo Market more »
The New Condo Market in the DC Metro: A Snapshot
Will Smith
February 2nd | 2 Comments
Real estate sales and marketing firm McWilliams|Ballard has released a report on the state of the... read »
- The New Condo Market in the DC Metro: A Snapshot
- DC Housing Report: November 2009
- The DC Condo Market, Part 5: The Top 20 Fastest Selling Condos
- The DC Condo Market, Part 4: The Coming Condo Shortage (Maybe)
- The DC Condo Market, Part 3: Where the New Condos Are
Green Real Estate more »
Row House Features DC’s First Solar Chimney
Fritz Hubig
January 21st | 4 Comments
When Wayne Shields and Andrew Velthaus approached designer Rick Harlan Schneider of iSTUDIO... read »
- Row House Features DC’s First Solar Chimney
- 900 North Washington Street: Old Town Condos Seeing Green
- DC’s First Carbon Neutral Home Hits the Market
- The Real Deal with LEED Certfication
- Unique Spaces: The DC Area’s First Net Zero Home
Deal of the Week more »
Deal of the Week: New Two-Bedroom For Under $370K in Shaw
Mark Wellborn
8:00 AM EST | 0 Comments
We know you missed it last week, but Deal of the Week is back today with a new two-bedroom,... read »
- Deal of the Week: New Two-Bedroom For Under $370K in Shaw
- Deal of the Week: Investor Special in Adams Morgan?
- Deal of the Week: Off Thomas Circle For Under $300K
- Deal of the Week: Hot Tubbin’ in Columbia Heights
- Deal of the Week: A Steal on Capitol Hill
Renting more »
Report Finds DC Rents Rising Faster Than Other U.S. Cities
Mark Wellborn
February 7th | 1 Comment
If you have thought that your monthly rent has been increasing steadily over the past few years,... read »
Condo Buyers more »
FHA Changes Could Have Substantial Effect on Condo Buyers
Tim Brown
February 8th | 1 Comment
A few weeks ago, the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) introduced several changes to the... read »
UrbanTurf Reader Asks more »
What Will Streetcars Do For Property Values?
Mark Wellborn
February 1st | 11 Comments
In this week’s installment of UrbanTurf Reader Asks, a reader who is in the market for his first... read »
Ask an Agent more »
Should I Buy a Parking Space That is Separate From My Unit?
Mark Wellborn
December 9th | 2 Comments
In this week's installment of Ask An Agent, a reader who bought a condo last year wonders if he... read »
Best New Listings more »
Best New Listings: Logan Circle and AU Park (Week of Feb 8th)
Mark Wellborn
February 8th | 0 Comments
This week's Best New Listings include a high-end one-bedroom on the southern edge of Logan Circle... read »
- Best New Listings: Logan Circle and AU Park (Week of Feb 8th)
- Best New Listings: Logan Circle and LeDroit Park (Week of Feb 1st)
- Best New Listings: Petworth, Columbia Heights and Dupont Circle (Week of Jan 25th)
- Best New Listings: Eckington and Del Ray (Week of Jan 18th)
- Best New Listings: 16th Street Heights and U Street Corridor (Week of Jan 11th)
Luxury Real Estate more »
How Much to Live in a Lake Tahoe Ski Villa?
Mark Wellborn
February 5th | 7 Comments
In honor of the snow that just started falling and to make all those skiers and snowboarders out... read »
- How Much to Live in a Lake Tahoe Ski Villa?
- “If I Had $1.5 Million” Listing: Spacious Loft Penthouse in Capitol Hill
- “If I Had $1.5 Million” Listing: Five-Bedroom Contemporary in Palisades
- The Price to Live in a California Indoor/Outdoor Home Revealed
- “If I Had $3 Million” Listing: Enormous Condo Near The Swedish Embassy




















































20 Comments
Mount Pleasant. I think it is perhaps the best neighborhood in DC for young homebuyers.
Petworth may soon be just as lively as Mount Pleasant and you can pay less for a home that will show more return on your investment in a couple years. So I say Petworth.
The answer to this question is fairly straightforward. You’ll pay $200,000 less for an equivalent house in Petworth, but the tradeoff for your 200k is less certainty about the neighborhood. If Petworth takes off in 5-10 years you’ll be in great shape. If not, you’ll be better off in Mt Pleasant. If you like both equally, it’s really about whether you want to take the gamble on higher upside.
Really depends where in Petworth. If it’s by the Petworth metro I can understand why you’re struggling with the decision. If it’s further north than Varnum then the decision for Mt Pleasant should be much easier.
Houses in Mt P are quite a bit more expensive and in 5 years Petworth may well have nearly as much to offer in terms of shops, restaurants, etc. And if Metro-accessibility is important to you, then the specific block is probably more important to consider - there are parts of Mt P that are pretty far from the Metro. If schools are important then Mt P might be worth it (I think it’s in the Wilson HS district) but otherwise, I think Petworth is a better value. I mean, why would you pay $200k more for a comparable house if you like the neighborhoods equally well?
I seriously doubt the reader is considering two houses that are 200K apart in price. Let’s not take the little embellishment introduced by Darnell and run with it as an actual fact of the case at hand…
Lets also not overstate the trajectory of housing prices in Petworth. There will be a fairly significant price difference between these two neighborhoods for years, which is a strong reason to buy in MP.
Well, I really wanted to buy a rowhouse in Mount Pleasant, but at the time rowhouses in Mt. Pleasant were $650-900K and in Petworth they were $350K to 550K. I bought in Petworth because it was the most affordable neighborhood that reminded me of Mt. Pleasant, where even the cheapest houses were way outside my price range.
So if you can afford to buy in Mt. Pleasant go ahead and do that, it’s a great neighborhood. But I really have trouble imagining someone who could afford to buy in both places struggling with the decision. I can see Mt. Pleasant vs. Columbia Heights and Petworth vs. Brookland or Shaw, but Petworth and Mt. Pleasant are in totally different categories.
Re: SimonF’s comment - “There will be a fairly significant price difference between these two neighborhoods for years, which is a strong reason to buy in MP.” My response is there’s a lot more room for upward mobility in Petworth and I think it’s undervalued. I think it’s more a question of what you want now vs. potential for the future. I think in Petworth you have the potential to gain from both the market strengthening and the neighborhood changing, while in Mt. Pleasant the increased prices mark a neighborhood that most people think has already “arrived.”
buy in columbia heihts, best of both
I think the reader’ issue is whether she is more interested in saving money on a home that could be worth something down the line versus paying top dollar (which she probably has) for a home in an established area like Mt. Pleasant. That said, I am with the Petworth detractors here. I think the neighborhood has a ways to go until property values start really increasing.
To me the issue isn’t about potential appreciation - I mean, sure it’s nice to see something you own go up in value but is that really the main point of buying a house? But the person asking the question said she liked the neighborhoods “equally well” and since houses in Petworth are quite a bit cheaper, why wouldn’t she buy there? I mean, even if she can afford Mount Pleasant, isn’t it nice to not have a huge % of your paycheck eaten up by your mortgage? And to the person questioning whether it’s really a $200k difference - it is when you compare apples to apples - as an example a renovated 3br within .5 mile of the Metro would be $700k in MtP and $500k in Petworth.
Why not try Sixteenth Street Heights? Some houses are as large or larger than in Mt. Pleasant, it has a slightly more suburban feel, and is as equally convenient, tho’ Metro is a bit of a hike. Killer bus lines on 14th & 16th St. Close to Rock Creek Park. Lower crime than Petworth. Boundaries are 16th St to the west, Arkansas to the south, 14th St. to the east, and Kennedy to the north. Three very active neighborhood associations are in that area, too.
I have lived in Petworth for several years and the amount of growth I have seen in just the past 6 months is huge. The areas closest to the metro are your best bet and will easily outpace any home in Mt Pleasant as far as increase in value over the next 3 to 5 years. Mt Pleasant has no metro and that is an issue for a lot of buyers. Values in Mt Pleasant do not have as much room to grow and there is very little that is going to change in that neighborhood. Petworth is one of the few neighborhoods that is actually seeing new business and development happening. I would go with Petworth.
Go with Petworth. Larger homes, smaller mortgage, greater potential and soon enough much more convenient. Tons of individuals just like you are moving in.
are you serious? MP wins hands down. Petworth is just too dangerous!
As someone who has recently rented in Mt Pleasant and purchased in Petworth, I feel my opinion is a fair one.
Mt Pleasant is a gorgeous, cloistered neighborhood. It has decent bus access, and is (mostly) within manageable walking distance to metro. In a lot of ways, it reminds me of Georgetown.
Petworth is a neighborhood on the rise. Development on Georgia Ave, which was non-existent for deacdes, is now booming. The extension of the yellow line metro a few years back significantly increased its ease of accessibility. Violent crime has continued to seem to be more of a problem than other parts of NW in recent history.
The prices reflect the state of gentrification
in both neighborhoods. Whereas I had a variety of good 3-4 BR options in my price range in Petworth (500ish), the only things in my price range in Mt P were either rowhouse shells (which were actually closer to 600) or tiny places right off of 16th St that offered little more room than a 2BR condo.
So, to repeat what others have said…if you can afford Mt. P, it’s a great neighborhood now - but don’t expect huge investment potential. If you need more space or want a lot more bang for your buck, and can deal with
some transitional pains…Petworth is the place for you.
well if you like the neighborhoods equally, then go with the cheaper option.
personally, I prefer Mt Pleasant over Petworth for 2 reasons: it’s pretty and the crime is not so high.
Have any of you people actually read MPD crime stats? Mount Pleasant is way more dangerous than Petworth. Petwroth gets a bad rep because Black people live there. And for too many people black=crime. But if you actually look at the stats, lots more robberies and violent crimes in MP.
And don’t forget, if you like both neighborhoods, each one is just a short H8 bus ride away.
I recently purchased in Petworth, having found a terrific rowhouse as a result of relaxing my criteria on location. It’s all about the trade-offs. I’ve lived in Columbia Heights for over five years, just before the big changes started (the new Giant, Wonderland, Red Rocks, Target…) It’s no news to anyone that CH has significantly changed in that time, but to see it first hand has been an education. I remember reviewing the city’s CH development plan online years ago, and having revisited that plan it appears much of that has been realized. Now I see the same movement on Georgia Ave. And pockets all over DC that were once dead are now defining interesting—a province once held exclusively by the somewhat overrated corridors of Dupont Circle, Mt. Pleasant, and Adams Morgan. Aside from the house, what drew me into Petworth was the quiet, residential streets that kept me close enough (but not too close) to the action. And for all the talk about crime, I compared my current CH address to PW, and found my CH address experienced 5 times the number of crime incidents in the past year. Violent crimes are proportionetly higher in PW, which is what likely contributes to its scarier rep, but not greater in number. In fact, they matched addresses in Dupont Circle. So do your homework, trust your gut, and figure out what matters to you the most. What other people say gives you some sense of market buzz, but this decision is yours.